Volusia County Sheriff's Office
Home | news | Update: Sheriff's Detectives, Deputies Arrest 12 in Orange City Drug Sweep / Efforts Continue to Clean Up Sunset Ave. Property
Aside arrow Update: Sheriff's Detectives, Deputies Arrest 12 in Orange City Drug Sweep / Efforts Continue to Clean Up Sunset Ave. Property
October 17, 2019 3:10 pm

Laura Williams,
Office of Media Relations & Public Affairs

‘Operation Meth-O-Ween’ Continues Effort to Clean Up Sunset Ave. Property

**(Original news release from May 2018 appears below update.)

Volusia Sheriff’s Office deputies and detectives once again arrested several people at a problem Orange City property known for drug activity, making 12 arrests to follow up the 21 arrests made there last year.

This week’s “Operation Meth-O-Ween” at 711 Sunset Ave., known as CJ’s Nursery, was part of an ongoing effort to clean up criminal activity there. In May 2018, the Sheriff’s Office executed search warrants at that community in a months-long investigation and arrested 21 people, mostly on drug charges.

Early Wednesday, 12 of 17 people found at the property were arrested. Here are the defendants and charges:

• Kathleen Lauby, 39        (DOB: 11-26-79)     Sale of methamphetamine within 1,000 feet of a school, possession of methamphetamine, possession of heroin, possession of alprazolam, possession of clonazepam, possession of paraphernalia;   

• Michael Benner, 43        (DOB: 12-19-75)     Sale of methamphetamine, possession of methamphetamine, possession of alprazolam, possession of paraphernalia;   

• Clayton Leach, 42         (DOB: 12-01-76)      Possession of methamphetamine, possession of paraphernalia;  

• Sherry Readore, 48       (DOB: 8-11-71)        Possession of paraphernalia; 

• Lauren Boals, 40           (DOB 12-14-78)        Possession of methamphetamine, possession of paraphernalia;      

• Andrew Wallace, 37      (DOB: 6-20-82)         Possession of methamphetamine, possession of paraphernalia;

• Shannon Staley, 45      (DOB: 10-20-74)        Possession of methamphetamine, possession of paraphernalia;

• Matthew Farthing, 40   (DOB: 8-26-79)          Possession of ammo by convicted felon;

• Maria Agosto, 28         (DOB: 12-06-90)         Possession of fentanyl, possession of paraphernalia, resisting without violence;

• James Brown, 49         (DOB:  01-07-70)        Possession of methamphetamine;

• Gregory Jack, 32         (DOB: 06-23-87)         VOP warrant reference possession of sch. II;

• David Stroud, 19         (DOB: 05-19-2000)      Resisting without violence

Wednesday’s search netted seizure of these items: 3 grams of methamphetamine; 1 gram of heroin; .5 grams of fentanyl; 33.5 Alprazolam pills; 5 Clonazepam pills;    $2,545; drug paraphernalia.



May 2, 2018

Laura Williams, 
Office of Media Relations & Public Affairs



Twenty-one suspects living at a community at 711 Sunset Ave., Orange City, were rounded up early Tuesday as part of “Operation The Sun Has Set.” Most were arrested on narcotics charges after two search warrants were executed by detectives with the West Volusia Narcotics Task Force.

The months-long investigation at the property, known as CJ’s Nursery, began after complaints, tips and anonymous phone calls to the task force detailing ongoing drug activity there. Two search warrants were executed early Tuesday at a two-story residence and a second home on the property, with the assistance of officers from these units: Sheriff’s Office SWAT, East Volusia Narcotics Task Force, VCSO Districts 2 and 6 Criminal Investigations Divisions, Deltona Narcotics Enforcement Team and the Orange City Police Department.

The second warrant was secured after further investigation led detectives to the second home and probable cause that people in the residence were also involved in drug activity and harboring fugitives.

Out of 27 people found on the property, 21 were arrested. The homeowner/property owner, Charles Mascaro, (DOB: 01/16/56), lives on the property. He was charged with possession of cocaine, possession of meth with intent to distribute and possession of drug paraphernalia.

Here are the remaining defendants and their charges:

•Robert Blane Pursley    (DOB: 01-17-86)           Poss of Heroin , Poss of drug paraphernalia

•Steven Dobos               (DOB: 02-07-68)           Driving While License Suspended WARRANT

•Jason Allen Belcher      (DOB: 09-11-85)            VOP-Grand Theft / Poss of drug paraphernalia    

•Clayton Leach               (DOB: 12-01-76)            Poss of meth, Poss of drug paraphernalia

•Alicia Thomas               (DOB: 02-01-78)            Poss of drug paraphernalia

•Nicole Doyle                 (DOB: 12-17-92)            VOP WARRANT-Poss of heroin, sale of meth WARRANT, poss of drug paraphernalia

•MaryBeth Abello           (DOB: 11-14-80)            Poss of drug paraphernalia

•Lauren Boals                (DOB: 12-14-78)            Poss of meth, Poss of cocaine, Poss of drug paraphernalia

•John Hall III                  (DOB: 01-29-74)            Sale of meth WARRANT

•Gene Cutlip                  (DOB: 09-23-80)            Littering over 500 lbs

•Cheryl Small                 (DOB: 11-05-68)            Poss of meth, poss of drug paraphernalia

•Marlon Stafford             (DOB: 08-26-73)            Writ of bodily possession

•Sabrina Trefren             (DOB: 05-02-77)            Poss of drug paraphernalia

•Stephanie Mack            (DOB: 05-04-82)            Poss of drug paraphernalia    

•Crystal Shaffer              (DOB: 04-01-82)            Poss of meth, Poss of drug paraphernalia

•Tracie Powers               (DOB:10-30-74)             Poss of meth, Poss of drug paraphernalia

•Sherry Readore             (DOB: 08-11-71)            Poss of meth, Poss of drug paraphernalia

•Matthew Kunzig             (DOB: 08-12-68)            Poss of Cocaine, Poss of paraphernalia    

•Craig Ralls                    (DOB: 12-11-68)            VOP and Poss. of heroin, methamphetamine and paraphernalia

•Alesia Doyle                 (DOB: 12-13-88)        Poss. of a firearm by convicted felon; poss. of Heroin; poss of Meth; poss sch. 4 Tramadol;  poss of sch. 2 Amphetamine; poss of sch. 2 Oxycodone; poss of sch. 2  Morphine; poss of sch. 2 Hydrocodone; poss of sch. 4 Carisprodol; poss of sch.5 Buprenorphine; poss of paraphernalia 

Tuesday’s search netted seizure of: a .35-caliber rifle; 8 grams of meth; 2.3 grams of heroin; 2 grams cannabis; 8 grams hash; 9.5 Amphetamine; 8 Alprazolam,;1 Oxycodone; 2 Tramadol; 3 uprenorphine; 1 Carisprodol; 1 Morphine; 7 Hydrocodone; 1.7 grams cocaine; and 1.25 grams crack-cocaine located throughout the property.

In addition to narcotics charges being levied, Volusia County Code Enforcement and Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission officers also were on scene and found multiple environmental law violations. They will follow up with additional charges.

Detectives say the people that frequent this property are responsible for a significant amount of property crimes that take place every day in West Volusia. Tuesday’s arrests will likely have a positive impact on the community and reduce the amount of property crimes in the area.

Volusia County Sheriff's Office


Administrative offices: West Volusia 386-736-5961 Daytona Beach 386-254-4689 New Smyrna Beach 386-423-3352

Non-emergency dispatch numbers: DeLand 386-943-8276 Daytona Beach 386-239-8276 New Smyrna Beach 386-409-8276 Osteen 407-323-0151

Privacy Policy | Web Accessibility Policy


We use cookies to provide and improve our services. By using our site, you consent to cookies.